Anime or manga about manga

SecretWish
Rouge pirate

(05-12-2018, 08:25 PM)Sindar Wrote: If you were referring to the popularity of Mangirl on a particular forum that you are visiting you should have said so. I can't read your mind you know : P In general though this is one of the many series that no one cared when it was airing and it was completely forgotten soon after =) I watched it though.

you shouldn't jump to conclusions with what little you know. you will be surprised how many people like it in yo. i don't have any pinion to it.

Reply
Sindar
Retired Staff

(05-13-2018, 04:57 PM)SecretWish Wrote: you shouldn't jump to conclusions with what little you know. you will be surprised how many people like it in yo. i don't have any pinion to it.

Oh yes I can Tongue Obviously I don't know or care what people on yo think, I am talking about the popularity in general. Mangirl! has been ranked 2500th popularity-wise on MAL, only 22,551 members saw it. Considering its airing date and demographics, that is enough for me to say it was a flop. Even other 5 min per episode tv series that was airing at the time like Aiura and Yama no Susume did considerably better. People have even cited those are pioneers in short format tv production, which is kinda fun to think about considering how silly these shows are.

Reply
Claraviolet
Akatsuki

(05-13-2018, 04:57 PM)SecretWish Wrote: you shouldn't jump to conclusions with what little you know. you will be surprised how many people like it in yo. i don't have any pinion to it.


Your information is inconsistent secret wish. I know that you are referring to some other forum, but none of us have been to that forum and we don't know what kind of discussions are taking place there. 
So if you are talking about an anime, please consider it in general popularity.

[Image: YqKb33u.png?1]


[Only registered and activated users can see links Click here to register]
Reply
SecretWish
Rouge pirate

(05-13-2018, 10:18 PM)Sindar Wrote: Oh yes I can Tongue Obviously I don't know or care what people on yo think, I am talking about the popularity in general. Mangirl! has been ranked 2500th popularity-wise on MAL, only 22,551 members saw it. Considering its airing date and demographics, that is enough for me to say it was a flop. Even other 5 min per episode tv series that was airing at the time like Aiura and Yama no Susume did considerably better. People have even cited those are pioneers in short format tv production, which is kinda fun to think about considering how silly these shows are.

for me, yo is like mal. you are all just being hypocritic for accepting mal and not accepting yo

Reply
Sindar
Retired Staff

(05-14-2018, 02:47 PM)SecretWish Wrote: for me, yo is like mal. you are all just being hypocritic for accepting mal and not accepting yo

Does it have 5 million members? Smile

(This post was last modified: 05-15-2018, 01:46 AM by Sindar.)

Reply
SecretWish
Rouge pirate

(05-15-2018, 01:46 AM)Sindar Wrote: Does it have 5 million members? Smile

it has 400k registered members but many people visit it but doesn't make accounts. there are afraid some homophobe would find it and the would be bullied

Reply
Sindar
Retired Staff

(05-15-2018, 01:37 PM)SecretWish Wrote: it has 400k registered members but many people visit it but doesn't make accounts. there are afraid some homophobe would find it and the would be bullied

Wow that is impressive :O Then the stats from that site do need to be takes with some seriousness. If they publish any stats - let me know. What is the full name of the site?

Reply
SecretWish
Rouge pirate

(05-16-2018, 01:21 AM)Sindar Wrote: Wow that is impressive :O Then the stats from that site do need to be takes with some seriousness. If they publish any stats - let me know. What is the full name of the site?

i already told you it's yaoi otaku. if you google, you will get it as the first link. please don't ban me as the other user asked me for it

Reply


Users browsing this thread:

1 Guest(s)