Mikasa Ackerman vs. Batgirl

Elvis
Rouge pirate

Who would win in a fight?

[Only registered and activated users can see links Click here to register]

vs.

[Only registered and activated users can see links Click here to register]

Reply
Claraviolet
Akatsuki

Hmm...dunno.
I know mikasa but I don't know who batgirl is. I only know batman o.O

[Image: YqKb33u.png?1]


[Only registered and activated users can see links Click here to register]
Reply
MadaraUchiha
Akatsuki

Well, we are talking about a woman who was trained by Batman himself, so Batgirl must have serious combat capabilities. Plus, pre-time is a factor here. If she has prep-time she can win. The problem here is, Mikasa is an aggressive beast who doesn't hesitate to kill, but Batgirl doesn't kill. Mikasa can be pretty unhinged and psychotic at times.

" Justice is subject to dispute; might is easily recognized and is not disputed. So we cannot give might to justice, because might has gainsaid justice, and has declared that it is she herself who is just. And thus, being unable to make what is just strong, we have made what is strong just."
Reply
BurnsyCEO
NBF member

I have no idea what batgirl's arsenel includes but if she can do the disappearing into darkness trick as well as batman and has similar gadgets, batgirl for sure.

[Image: APm3rbC]
Reply
VirusZero
Member

I'm going to use Deathbattle's rules here since they make sense. In case you have no idea what they are... 
1- any inhibition against killing is removed. 
2- No outside help.
3- No prep time. 
4- Fight ends in death.

Which means for me, Batgirl would win. 

Mikasa is pretty good in a fight but she relies extremely heavily on her 3D manoeuvring gear to do so.  She also is used to fighting predominantly larger and slower foes. This means fighting another human becomes a lot riskier and trickier. 

Batgirl on the other hand is used to fighting opponents with blades so she knows how to handle them. In some cases her batsuit has armoured sections which make it harder to get to her. (Piercing/stabbing might still work, but the AoT blades are designed for slashing so their effectiveness would be limited here.) It's also worth mentioning that Batgirl has far superior training for fighting hand to hand than Mikasa does. Mikasa's training centred mostly on fighting titans (though some hand to hand too). 

Batgirl also has the edge because she typically packs a quantity of batarangs (shuriken like projectiles) that could easily catch Mikasa off guard. (Or, in worst case sever Mikasa's 3D gear grappling hooks and severely limit Mikasa's movement.)  Any attack on the 3D gear means Mikasa is going to lose any speed/mobility advantage she might have had. (And it's not like she can release and retract the grapples quick enough to stop Batgirl from hitting them. If she did, she'd risk falling out of the air and suffering injury. )  
Though Batgirl also has some aerial mobility too with her grappling gun. Perhaps not as much as Mikasa due to having to use a hand to do it where Mikasa's hands are free to use her blades. But I wouldn't discount Batgirl over this.

Reply
Star_Of_Hope
Akatsuki

(12-13-2017, 04:06 PM)VirusZero Wrote: I'm going to use Deathbattle's rules here since they make sense. In case you have no idea what they are... 
1- any inhibition against killing is removed. 
2- No outside help.
3- No prep time. 
4- Fight ends in death.

Which means for me, Batgirl would win. 

Mikasa is pretty good in a fight but she relies extremely heavily on her 3D manoeuvring gear to do so.  She also is used to fighting predominantly larger and slower foes. This means fighting another human becomes a lot riskier and trickier. 

Batgirl on the other hand is used to fighting opponents with blades so she knows how to handle them. In some cases her batsuit has armoured sections which make it harder to get to her. (Piercing/stabbing might still work, but the AoT blades are designed for slashing so their effectiveness would be limited here.) It's also worth mentioning that Batgirl has far superior training for fighting hand to hand than Mikasa does. Mikasa's training centred mostly on fighting titans (though some hand to hand too). 

Batgirl also has the edge because she typically packs a quantity of batarangs (shuriken like projectiles) that could easily catch Mikasa off guard. (Or, in worst case sever Mikasa's 3D gear grappling hooks and severely limit Mikasa's movement.)  Any attack on the 3D gear means Mikasa is going to lose any speed/mobility advantage she might have had. (And it's not like she can release and retract the grapples quick enough to stop Batgirl from hitting them. If she did, she'd risk falling out of the air and suffering injury. )  
Though Batgirl also has some aerial mobility too with her grappling gun. Perhaps not as much as Mikasa due to having to use a hand to do it where Mikasa's hands are free to use her blades. But I wouldn't discount Batgirl over this.


Is she could take down Giants, humans would never pose a problem for Mikasa.
So may be she would win

[Image: 6bc972f0df4d014940d3f6dfd1a3a9be.png]
Reply
VirusZero
Member

Mikasa isn't fighting a titan here, any speed/agility advantage that she might have is negated by the fact of her target is much smaller and also is very agile. (Don't fall into the trap of "because <character> beat <other character> then they'd win against <third other character>".) If anything the titans size is what works against them. 


Additionally Titans are, for the most part, stupid. They don't generally try to block their weak point or anything like that. They don't normally have complex strategies. They don't try to go after the 3D gear. They don't even care about it. Which is something that Batgirl would definitely care about... she would most assuredly be watching what Mikasa did and plan to counter it. 

Plus Batgirl has ways to counter the 3D gear that most Titans don't. And Mikasa really wouldn't be able to do much to stop Batgirl's attack. I mean Mikasa relies almost exclusively on her blades and 3D gear to fight. Take those away from her and Batgirl's superior training would mean the end of Mikasa.

Reply


Users browsing this thread:

1 Guest(s)